How F. Scott Fitzgerald introduces characters in Gatsby

Whether you are writing a short story or a long novel, you need to introduce characters into your narrative.  One mistake many of my students make is to rely on “is” and “are” to describe characters.  “Her hair is blonde and her eyes are blue.”  “He was about five feet, three inches tall, and his hair was white.”

Scott Fitzgerald had the same need to describe characters as he introduced them in The Great Gatsby. Below are Fitzgerald’s words introducing some of his most important characters.  Notice how few times he uses the verb “to be” and how much he describes personalities rather than physical appearances.

Daisy “made an attempt to rise—she leaned slightly forward with a conscientious expression—then she laughed, an absurd, charming little laugh, and I laughed too.”  Do we know what Daisy looks like?  No.  The first thing we know is that she laughs and makes others happy.  Maybe that’s why Gatsby has loved her all these years?  Immediately we like her.

Tom Buchanan in riding clothes was standing with his legs apart on the front porch. . . .he was a sturdy, straw haired man of thirty with a rather hard mouth and a supercilious manner.  Two shining, arrogant eyes had established dominance over his face.”  We know from his posture that Tom is a man’s man–nothing feminine about him–and from his mouth that he has a tough, unforgiving nature, and from his manner that he is arrogant.  Right away we fear Tom, and rightly so.  Nothing is lighthearted about him.

Myrtle Wilson “a thickish figure of a woman blocked out the light from the office door. . . .but she carried her surplus flesh sensuously.”  Myrtle’s stout figure surprises us since by the time she is introduced we know she is Tom’s mistress.  That last word, “sensuously,” tells us all we need to know about Tom’s and Myrtle’s relationship.  From this initial description we pity Myrtle for attaching herself to a fearsome man like Tom.

“’I’m Gatsby,’ he said suddenly. . . .’I thought you knew, old sport.  I’m afraid I’m not a very good host.’  He smiled understandingly—much more than understandingly.  It was one of those rare smiles with a quality of eternal reassurance in it.”  Gatsby introduces himself to the narrator, Nick, with an apology, but he immediately smiles—and what a smile!  No mention of Gatsby’s age or physique or party clothes.  Rather, we appreciate Gatsby’s charm as shown by his words and smile.  We like Gatsby.

To introduce these characters, Fitzgerald focuses on a characteristic of personality which is vital to our relating to that character.  Laughter, a hard edge, sexiness, and a smile.  Two of the four characters have no physical description at all.

Can you duplicate Fitzgerald’s technique?  Read over this paragraph about a dog, and then rewrite it.  Describe the dog’s appearance but also give the dog an attitude.

The original:

The door opens and out comes a dog.  It’s a fat black pug on short legs.  He has bulging black eyes, a pressed-in face, and a wrinkled neck.

Here is one rewrite:

The crate door opens and out rushes a chubby black pug on puny legs.  His bulging black eyes dart from left to right above his snorting mouth.  He marches as if on a mission—no sauntering for him—bee-lining to his water bowl where he lowers his heavy head on its velvety, wrinkled neck.

And here’s another:

The car door slides to reveal a black pug sniffing the air and studying the distance to the ground.  He waits on truncated legs too short to jump.  His master encircles the pug’s velvety neck with one hand, lifts his weighty belly with the other, and lowers him to the grass.  The pug sniffs, scuffs in a circle three times, and pees.  He paws at the grass to cover his business and struts.  His master snaps on his leash and walks ahead, calling the pug to follow.  But the mighty pug recognizes the vet’s doorway, digs in his hind legs, and balks.  No staying in a kennel for me, mister.

Should students use AI in English classrooms?

Suppose you assign your high school students to write an essay on transgender athletes.  It’s a topic to which the regulatory bodies of various sports have responded differently (or not at all). It’s controversial, current and abounding in opinions—a good topic for an essay.

Should you allow your student to use AI to write this essay?  If so, at what point in the writing process?

The writing process begins with narrowing down the topic into a main idea or thesis.  A good way for a student to do this is to read widely on the topic until a position emerges in the student’s mind.  Then the student should narrow this position further, list three or four supporting ideas and identify details and examples to explain these supporting ideas.

This kind of thinking is what schools call critical thinking.  It involves understanding a topic by analyzing it, by evaluating various parts of the topic to see how they would support or undermine a position, and by synthesizing or bringing together ideas in a unique way.  Then students order the ideas, write sentences and paragraphs, and figure out what to put in the introduction and conclusion.  Last comes revising: polishing the writing by improving vocabulary and sentence structure, adding better information, deleting irrelevant information, and fixing grammar, spelling and punctuation problems.

But what if your student begins by asking AI for an essay thesis relating to transgender athletes.  In a nanosecond, a thesis appears.  Your student asks for three supporting ideas.  In another nanosecond, the supporting information appears.  Your student reads over AI’s suggestions and concurs.  Your student asks AI to write the essay in 350 to 400 words with a striking introduction, three body paragraphs and a humorous conclusion.  In another nanosecond, the essay appears.  Done.

Which way do you want students working–by thinking deeply about the topic or by asking AI to think for them?  Through which method do students learn?

If you want your students to do the work, one way to tell if they do and have learned from the process is to demand that the prewriting notes, organization graphic/chart/bullets, and the first drafts be turned in with the essay.  Another is to ask students to paraphrase their thesis and subtopic ideas.  If they can’t put their essay’s ideas in their own words, do they really understand what “they” wrote?  Another is to ask students what positions they declined to take and why.  If students have a full understanding of the topic, they will be able to explain why they took a certain position as well as why they didn’t take another.

For most high school students I have worked with—maybe all—using AI would not be in their self-interest.  Making mistakes and learning from them is a far better approach to learning.  Students, like athletes, need to have skin in the game.  If students have allowed AI to make the choices in their essays, students have no stake in the assignment.  It’s like having a robot run the 200 meter or swim the 400 IM.  For students to achieve, they have to do the work.

* * * *

Are you looking for a writing tutor for your student for the coming school year?  Contact me through this blog, and let’s discuss how I can help with online writing classes for grades 4 through 12, and for college admissions essays.

 

 

Chart Method of note-taking

Note-taking is one of those skills that some teachers assume students know.  But many students have never been taught this skill essential for school success.  Below is one note-taking method.

The Chart Method of note-taking is recording information in chart or table form.  It is a good method to note data or facts.  Below is an example of a Chart Method of note-taking.

Ages of US Presidents

 

 

 

*President Grover Cleveland was inaugurated two times with a gap of four years between his two inaugurations.  He is counted twice in this category for an age of 47 at his first inauguration and an age of 55 at his second.
**Several past presidents are alive and are not included in this category.

To use this method of note-taking, the notetaker first determines what the main categories of the chart are.  These become the headings of the columns.  Next the notetaker draws the table.  In rows labeled to the left, the notetaker lists key points to be included under each column.

The chart method of note-taking has many advantages:

  • The chart is a clear visual representation of information.
  • The layout allows a quick comparison of the data.
  • Usually, no sentences need be written, streamlining the note-taking.
  • Anyone can quickly retrieve information from the chart.
  • Charts are adaptable to many subjects.
  • Charts aid in pattern recognition.
  • Charts are well organized.

The chart method of note-taking has disadvantages:

  • Information which is not readily broken down into categories is not well suited for chart note-taking.
  • At the start of a lecture, a student might not realize a chart is useful for the material to be covered, so the student might not draw one.
  • Some categories might have no relevant data, and other categories might have numerous data.

Teachers can help students learn to take notes in chart form by modeling charts or by alerting students that a chart might be a good way to write the information about to be presented.

How important are apostrophes?

On many SAT exams, students face choosing either “its,” “it’s,” “its’,” “their,” they’re,” or “there” as an answer to a prompt.  For example, what is the correct answer for the following clause?

“Toward the end of the 1400s, as the Renaissance was reaching its height. . .”

  1. NO CHANGE
  2. it’s
  3. its’
  4. their

Colleges must think knowing how to spell “its” and “their” correctly is an important skill for college-bound students to use correctly.  Otherwise, why would questions about their spelling be on the exams?  But is knowing if an apostrophe is needed and how to use it really that important?

In northern England, the North Yorkshire Council voted recently to remove apostrophes from street names.  So, the former “St. Mary’s Walk” has been changed to “St. Marys Walk.”  Another change is from “King’s Walk” to “Kings Walk.”

The meaning of each street name is slightly different without the apostrophe.  But would you be confused if you were looking for an address?  When we say, “St. Mary’s Walk,” we don’t mention the apostrophe, yet we are understood.

English teachers spend hours of classroom time instilling in children the importance of using apostrophes correctly.  In the phrase, “the sisters bike,” do you know where the apostrophe goes?  Or even if an apostrophe is needed?  (Yes, an apostrophe is needed.  If it is one sister, the answer is between the “r” and “s.”  If it is two or more sisters, the answer is after the “s.”)

In contractions, the apostrophe takes the place of missing letters.  But don’t you understand “I dont know” as well as “I don’t know”?

What is spurring the dropping of apostrophes?  Computers.  Data bases.  Text messages.  Multitasking.  Frantic lives.  In our increasingly digital world, apostrophes are deemed unimportant.  On my phone, I need to shift to a different screen if I want to use an apostrophe and then shift back.  I still do that, but it takes time.  I notice my children don’t bother.  If we understand speech without apostrophes, why complicate things by using them in writing?

Grammar teachers may wonder if they have wasted their lives focusing on the correct use of apostrophes, quotation marks, and commas.  Cursive writing teachers may wonder the same.  For past generations, apostrophes were signs of a well educated person.  Today they still are, but that is changing.

By the way, the correct response to the question at the beginning of the blog is NO CHANGE.

Cornell Method of note-taking

The Cornell Method of note-taking

Note-taking is one of those skills that some teachers assume students know.  But many students have never been taught this skill essential for school success.

The Cornell Method of note-taking consists of sectioning off a piece of notebook paper (or a computer screen) to be used for various purposes.  A visual example and explanation are below.

The Cornell Method has advantages as a note-taking pattern:

  • Because the notes are paraphrased versions of the original, the note-taker needs to understand the original lecture or text as he or she takes notes; the note-taker is not merely a transcriber but an analyzer.
  • If the note-taker rereads the notes a few minutes after taking them, his or her chances to memorize the information increase since it is stated two or three times in the notes.
  • White space leaves room to fill in or clarify original notes.
  • If tests come weeks after the note-taking, the note-taker has sufficient notes to study from.
  • The unvarying structure of the method appeals to organized people.

 

The Cornell Method also has disadvantages:

  • Creating the blocks and using them properly is an advanced skill inappropriate for young students and even for some high school students.
  • Sticking to the format is challenging for students in a hurry, for perfectionists, and for creative types who want less imposed structure in their learning.
  • Many students will not reread their notes immediately after writing them, a key factor in the success of this method.