Category Archives: introducing characters

How F. Scott Fitzgerald introduces characters in Gatsby

Whether you are writing a short story or a long novel, you need to introduce characters into your narrative.  One mistake many of my students make is to rely on “is” and “are” to describe characters.  “Her hair is blonde and her eyes are blue.”  “He was about five feet, three inches tall, and his hair was white.”

Scott Fitzgerald had the same need to describe characters as he introduced them in The Great Gatsby. Below are Fitzgerald’s words introducing some of his most important characters.  Notice how few times he uses the verb “to be” and how much he describes personalities rather than physical appearances.

Daisy “made an attempt to rise—she leaned slightly forward with a conscientious expression—then she laughed, an absurd, charming little laugh, and I laughed too.”  Do we know what Daisy looks like?  No.  The first thing we know is that she laughs and makes others happy.  Maybe that’s why Gatsby has loved her all these years?  Immediately we like her.

Tom Buchanan in riding clothes was standing with his legs apart on the front porch. . . .he was a sturdy, straw haired man of thirty with a rather hard mouth and a supercilious manner.  Two shining, arrogant eyes had established dominance over his face.”  We know from his posture that Tom is a man’s man–nothing feminine about him–and from his mouth that he has a tough, unforgiving nature, and from his manner that he is arrogant.  Right away we fear Tom, and rightly so.  Nothing is lighthearted about him.

Myrtle Wilson “a thickish figure of a woman blocked out the light from the office door. . . .but she carried her surplus flesh sensuously.”  Myrtle’s stout figure surprises us since by the time she is introduced we know she is Tom’s mistress.  That last word, “sensuously,” tells us all we need to know about Tom’s and Myrtle’s relationship.  From this initial description we pity Myrtle for attaching herself to a fearsome man like Tom.

“’I’m Gatsby,’ he said suddenly. . . .’I thought you knew, old sport.  I’m afraid I’m not a very good host.’  He smiled understandingly—much more than understandingly.  It was one of those rare smiles with a quality of eternal reassurance in it.”  Gatsby introduces himself to the narrator, Nick, with an apology, but he immediately smiles—and what a smile!  No mention of Gatsby’s age or physique or party clothes.  Rather, we appreciate Gatsby’s charm as shown by his words and smile.  We like Gatsby.

To introduce these characters, Fitzgerald focuses on a characteristic of personality which is vital to our relating to that character.  Laughter, a hard edge, sexiness, and a smile.  Two of the four characters have no physical description at all.

Can you duplicate Fitzgerald’s technique?  Read over this paragraph about a dog, and then rewrite it.  Describe the dog’s appearance but also give the dog an attitude.

The original:

The door opens and out comes a dog.  It’s a fat black pug on short legs.  He has bulging black eyes, a pressed-in face, and a wrinkled neck.

Here is one rewrite:

The crate door opens and out rushes a chubby black pug on puny legs.  His bulging black eyes dart from left to right above his snorting mouth.  He marches as if on a mission—no sauntering for him—bee-lining to his water bowl where he lowers his heavy head on its velvety, wrinkled neck.

And here’s another:

The car door slides to reveal a black pug sniffing the air and studying the distance to the ground.  He waits on truncated legs too short to jump.  His master encircles the pug’s velvety neck with one hand, lifts his weighty belly with the other, and lowers him to the grass.  The pug sniffs, scuffs in a circle three times, and pees.  He paws at the grass to cover his business and struts.  His master snaps on his leash and walks ahead, calling the pug to follow.  But the mighty pug recognizes the vet’s doorway, digs in his hind legs, and balks.  No staying in a kennel for me, mister.

How many names are too many names?

When you start to write a novel or a short story, how many characters should you introduce in the first scene?

I picked up the novel of a new-to-me but best-selling author tonight and started reading.  On the first page (really a half page), five characters were introduced along with their relationships to each other.  On the second page, four more people were named and their relationships.  On the third page, one more.  Ten names and a web of who knows how many relationships in two and a half pages of text.  None of them were developed enough to know more than “he’s a detective,” “she’s an au pair,” “she’s giving the party” and “he’s got a crush on the au pair.”

A bit into the second page I was flipping back to the first page to remind myself  who was who.  Then, befuddled, I pulled out a piece of paper and drew family tree-like relationships to keep characters straight.

Should this be necessary?  How many names are too many names?

I have never read any guidance on this topic.  Yet a maximum number of names is an important criterion for me to use to determine if I will keep reading.  If I find myself needing to draw family trees, I ask myself, “Is this worth reading?”  “No,” I almost always decide.  If an author can’t figure out how to introduce characters without confusing me, then the author can’t be that good.  I put the book back on the shelf and move on.

In college I needed to read Anna Karenina in English 101.  At the front of my translation was a list of characters which at first intimidated me.  But I rarely  consulted it.  Tolstoy had a way of introducing characters without overloading my short-term memory.  For the heck of it, I just now checked to count how many characters Tolstoy introduced by name in that novel’s first scene (about two pages).  The answer–three:  Stiva, his wife, Dolly, and one man named as part of a silly dream, a man whose name we realize immediately is not important.  Other people’s roles are mentioned—a French governess, an English governess, a housekeeper, a cook, a kitchen-maid, a coachman, the children—but they are not named.  A reader needs to keep track of only two.  And one of those two we are learning about intimately since those pages are told from his point of view.

How many names are too many names?  I don’t know.  But when I am confused by the third page, that is too many names.